数字人文研究 ›› 2023, Vol. 3 ›› Issue (1): 61-78.

• 人文新知 • 上一篇    下一篇

对清代端慧皇太子永琏讳例的 e 考据

黄一农,台湾清华大学历史研究所特聘讲座教授   

  1. 黄一农,台湾清华大学历史研究所
  • 出版日期:2023-03-28 发布日期:2023-05-25

Naming taboo for Prince Yonglian, Hier Apparent Duanhui: An E-Textual Research Case Study

  • Online:2023-03-28 Published:2023-05-25

摘要: 本文透过 e 考据的研究方法,在梳理大量富含历史语境的文本之后,厘清了清代避端慧 皇太子永琏名讳的复杂状况。 此一讳例应起自嘉庆九年,帝为表达对已故兄长永琏的尊敬,谕命新任锦州知府的善琏将其名末一字改成“连”,但此前已任官者应获允可维持原名。 稍后则规定参加会试的考生不得以“琏”字命名(低阶官吏及百姓则未要求须严遵),故直迄清末,上层的官场少有人其名有“琏”字。 至于平常书写或刊刻书籍,遇“琏” 字并无特别规定,虽有以改字或缺末笔的方式敬避,惟未避者更多。 据此,可知无法单纯借由“琏”字的未改避,来推断文本(如出现贾琏一角的《红楼梦》脂本)抄写或成书的时间。

关键词: 端慧皇太子, 永琏, 避讳, 大数据, e 考据

Abstract: This paper clarifies the naming taboo for Prince Yonglian,Hier Apparent Duanhui. By analyzing a large number of textual evidence in relation to this tabooing case,this study uses e - textual research to shed new light on the complex naming taboo practices during the Qing dynasty. The first known case of naming taboo on Yonglian's name occurred in the ninth year of Jiaqing reign. To show respect towards his late brother,Jiaqing emperor ordered the newly appointed prefect of Jinzhou,Shanlian,to change the second character of his name to another " lian. " However, any previously appointed officials with this character in their names were permitted to keep their names. The tabooing rule then applied to anyone who took the provincial level exams. But this regulation did not extend to lower level clerks and commoners. For this reason,the character " lian" was almost obsolete among higher level officials through the late Qing. Nevertheless,such taboo was not enforced in books ( both manuscript and print). While there were instances where authors avoided the character by using an alternative character or omitting the last stroke in the character,such tabooing practice was not consistent or commonplace. This proves that the naming taboo for Yonglian was nowhere regulated enough to be used as proof for dating texts. For example,Jia Lian,a major character in the Dreams of the Red Chamber shares the character " lian" with Prince Yonglian. But I argue that one cannot date a specific version of said book solely based on whether Jia Lian's name was altered (or not) in observation of the naming taboo.

Key words: Hier Apparent Duanhui: Yonglian, the naming taboo, big data, e-textual research

中图分类号: